12 Best Commuting Bike Seats [Cushion & Comfort Balanced]

ApexBikes is reader-supported. We may earn an affiliate commission when you buy through the links on our site. Learn more.

Does your bicycle saddle feel uncomfortable? Does it contain cracks or a lot of wear and tear? If that is the case, then it is a clear sign that you should replace it with a brand new bike seat. Continuing to use a defective saddle can not only make your commutes less enjoyable but also lead to severe injuries. So hurry up and buy the best bike seat to enrich your daily commutes.

However, choosing a new bicycle saddle is easier said than done. There are so many options out there and it has to suit you and your riding style. That is why we are here to help. We have conducted an immense amount of research and testing to find out a selection of the finest bike seat for commuting. So without further ado, let’s take a look at these amazing saddles.

Buying Guide of Bike Seats for usage during Commuting

Bike Seats for Commuting

Image Source: vx360.com

1. Types of Bicycle Saddles

There are two main types of bike saddles. They are performance saddles and cushioning saddles. Performance saddles consist of a small amount of padding while cushioning saddles come with a maximum amount.

I. Performance saddles:

Performance saddles are usually quite narrow & lengthy in size. They have a very low amount of padding which enables them to offer incredible power transfer and almost no chafing while riding. They are usually seen on road bikes, touring bikes & mountain bikes.

II. Cushioning saddles:

Cushioning saddles are usually wider and come with a lot more padding. Also, they consist of springs that help to absorb shocks encountered on the road while riding. A feature you will commonly spot on these saddles is that they come with a short nose. Cushioning saddles are usually seen on recreational and cruising bicycles.

Major Factors of Bicycle Saddle

Image Source: bikecitizens.net

2. Types of Padding

There are two main types of padding that are the most common among bicycle saddles produced today. They are gel cushioning & foam cushioning.

I. Gel Cushioning

Gel cushioning provides immense comfort by taking the shape of your body. This type of padding is mostly preferred by casual riders so that they can experience maximum comfort during their recreational rides. The only major drawback of gel cushioning is that it gets tighter much faster when compared to foam padding.

II. Foam Cushioning

Foam cushioning provides a more flexible experience and comes back into its shape. Foam padding is preferred by most road riders as it offers both comfort and excellent support for the rider. Riders who prefer long rides or with great sit bones or even riders who weigh more than 200 pounds choose a solid foam padding over gel padding. This is because it does not become very tight too fast unlike gel cushioning.

A lot of bike saddles do not consist of any type of cushioning. Yes, that may sound a bit uncomfortable, however, over time and frequent use the saddle breaks in and conforms to your shape & weight. This allows it to become much more comfortable. Also, saddles without any padding tend to stay cooler than those with padding. Saddles that do not consist of any padding mostly come with cotton or leather saddle covers.

3. Cut-Out Section

A lot of bicycle saddles are made to protect your perineum area. Such saddles lower or gets rid of the material located at the center of the saddle. This enables the saddle to both relieve the pressure from the perineum which in turn allows it to increase the airflow & comfort for all those long rides.

As different people have different anatomies, a lot of riders prefer a relief channel. While others may prefer to get a saddle that comes with a small indentation. Some even prefer to have neither of the aforementioned options. It actually depends completely on you and your personal preferences.

4. Saddle Covers

Bicycle saddles are built with different types of materials which has an impact on its factors such as its time required to break-in, weight, whether it is waterproof or not, price, and of course flex. The two components of a saddle that helps to determine this are the saddle cover & rails.

I. Synthetic Covers:

Most of the bicycle saddles you will find right now are completely made up of synthetic materials. This includes everything from the padding to the shell and also the saddle cover. They are favored by a lot of riders. This is because saddles made up of synthetic materials are quite lightweight, require very low maintenance, and come with a very small break-in time.

II. Leather Covers:

Now let’s talk about leather. There are two types of leather saddles available. The first one is similar to synthetic saddles where the synthetic material is just replaced with a thin leather cover. The other type of leather saddle is just made up of leather and comes without any sort of cushioning. These saddles are not comfortable at first but after consistent use and a proper amount of time, they break-in and become personalized to your weight and body shape.

A drawback with leather saddles is that they are not waterproof. Therefore, you have to apply a leather conditioner to it quite often to maintain its quality. This will help to keep it safe from moisture and UV exposure.

III. Cotton Covers:

Very few saddles come with cotton covers. These types of covers are made in such a way that they can shift or stretch while you ride your bike. This will enable you to experience tremendous comfort and control while you pedal. Also, it is a well-known fact that cotton needs a much shorter amount of time to break-in compared to leather.

4. Saddle Rails

The rails of the bike’s saddle are basically the points through which the bike is connected. A majority of the saddles produced today come with two rails that are parallel to each other. These start from the saddle’s nose and run all the way to the rear of the saddle. A bike seat post is attached to the rails. Take a look at the list of saddle rail materials along with their descriptions to get a better idea.

I. Steel:

Steel is quite a strong and highly reliable material. However, it is fairly heavy as well, and so if the weight of your saddle is a concern for you, you should consider rails made from other materials.

II. Alloy:

Alloy materials such as Chromoly, are used to build rails to ensure their strength. Alloy rails are much lighter in terms of weight when compared to steel rails.

III. Titanium:

Titanium is a very light and strong material. It is known for consisting of superior vibration absorption ability. However, even though it has excellent features, they come at quite an expensive price.

IV. Carbon:

Similar to titanium, carbon is also very light in weight. Also, it can be designed to absorb a good amount of vibrations while riding. However, you will most likely find carbon rails on very expensive saddles.

Our Top Pick

Among all the products we found that the Selle SMP TRK Medium Saddle is the best one due to its technology, superior padding, and comfort. That is why we have picked this saddle as our “Overall Best Choice”.

Selle SMP TRK Medium Saddle

SMP Vacuum Technology, Excellent Padding, High Strength | Overall Best Choice

The Selle SMP TRK Medium Saddle is the best overall choice! It is built with the SMP Vacuum Technology which means that it represents the highest quality & standard. It provides superior comfort due to the very soft polyurethane while also maintaining very high strength due to the high-end build quality, shell material, and strong steel rails. Also, the well-positioned cut-out section is a great feature and will allow you to ride your bike without facing any sort of discomfort or difficulty. This saddle is an all-rounder and provides everything you need to have the best riding experience!

  • Best For: Touring, Trekking, City Riding
  • Gender: Unisex
  • Saddle Type:
  • Saddle Cover Material: SVT Velvet Touch
  • Cushioning Material: Polyurethane
  • Rail Material: FeC30 Steel Rails
  • Dimensions: 11.02” x 6.30” x 2.95”
  • Weight: 405 grams

 

A quick view of our list of the best bike seat that we have selected for commuting:

Bike SeatWeight (grams)Our Ratings
Brooks England B1752090
Selle SMP TRK40590
Terry 2019 Women's Butterfly25588
Fabric Scoop Pro19288
Brooks England C1746488
Selle SMP TRK48586
Ergon - SM Sport30585
Ergon - SFC3 Ergonomic Comfort39584
Fizik Antares R3 Versus EVO21583
Selle Royal Respiro42982
Selle Royal Scientia52081
Fabric Scoop Sport Radius Gel37478

How our selected commuting bike seats compare

SaddlePreviewBest ForGenderSaddle TypeSaddle Cover MaterialCushioning MaterialRail MaterialDimensionsWeight (grams)
Brooks England B17B17 Carved BlackBike CommutingMenPerformance SaddleVegetable Tanned LeatherNoneSteel rail with black powder coating10.8” x 6.9” x 2.6”520
Selle SMP TRK MediumSelle SMP TRK Medium Saddle, BlackTouring, Trekking, City RidingUnisexSVT Velvet TouchPolyurethaneFeC30 Steel Rails11.02” x 6.30” x 2.95”405
Terry 2019 Women's ButterflyTerry 2019 Women's Butterfly Ti Gel+ Bicycle Saddle - 21024Road & City RidingWomenPerformance SaddleLeather With Perforated Butterfly PatternFoam, GelTi-316 Rails10.3” x 6.1” x 2.95”255
Fabric Scoop ProFabric Scoop Pro SaddleCommuting, Cross-Country, Cyclocross, Gravel, RoadUnisexPerformance SaddleNylon CoverPU FoamCarbon Fiber Rails11.10” x 5.59”192
Brooks England C17C17 Black All WeatherCommuting, Gravel, RoadUnisexVulcanised Natural Rubber and Nylon TopNoneSteel Rail With Black Powder Coating11.14” x 6.46” x 2.05”464
Selle SMP TRK GelSelle SMP TRK Gel Saddle Black - MediumTrekking, City, TouringUnisexSVT CoverSoft Polyurethane + GELSteel Rails11.02” x 6.30”485
Ergon - SM Sport Ergonomic ComfortErgon - SM Sport Ergonomic Comfort Bicycle Saddle | for All Mountain, Trail, Gravel and Bikepacking Bikes | Mens | Small/Medium | BlackMountain BikingMenMicrofiber CoverOrthopedic Comfort FoamChromoly Rails10.59” x 6.30”305
Ergon - SFC3 Ergonomic ComfortErgon - SFC3 Ergonomic Comfort Bicycle Saddle | for Hybrid, Commuting and E-Bikes | Unisex | Two Sizes | BlackFitness, E-Bike, Sport, Touring, CommutingUnisexCushioned SaddleMicrofiber CoverOrthopedic Comfort Foam + Gel PadsSteel Rails13.25” x 7.5” x 2.25”395
Fizik Antares R3 Versus EVOFizik Antares R3 Versus EVO Road Bicycle Saddle w/K:ium RailsRoad BikingUnisexCushioned SaddleLight Microtex CoverComfort Core FoamAlloy Rails10.83” x 5.59”215
Selle Royal Respiro Soft AthleticSelle Royal Respiro Soft Athletic Bike Saddle - RoyalGel Cushion with Foam Matrix and Water Resistant Cool Cover Protection, Black, Medium (5130HRTA891L4)Recreational RidingUnisexCushioned SaddleSynthetic CoverGel PaddingSteel Rails10.9” x 6.4”429
Selle Royal Scientia RelaxedSelle Royal Scentia Relaxed SaddleRoad BikingUnisexCushioned SaddleSynthetic Cover3D Skin GelSteel Rails11.38” x 8.82”520
Fabric Scoop Sport Radius GelFabric Scoop Sport Radius Gel SaddleGreat for all types of cyclingUnisexCushioned SaddleMicrofiber CoverGel CushioningSteel Rails10.24” x 6.10”374

12 best bike seat that you can buy today for commuting

1. Brooks England B17 saddle 

High Quality, Classic Style, Incredible Durability | Best Leather Choice

Sale
Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle
  • Best For: Bike Commuting
  • Gender: Men
  • Saddle Type: Performance Saddle
  • Saddle Cover Material: Vegetable Tanned Leather
  • Cushioning Material: None
  • Rail Material: Steel rail with black powder coating
  • Dimensions: 10.8” x 6.9” x 2.6”
  • Weight: 520 grams

Features & Considerations
  • Made in England: The B17 Saddle is Brooks England’s chief model. It is made in England and so certifies its top of the line quality and standard.
  • Classic Design: This saddle comes with a vintage, and stylish appearance. It will definitely match your bicycle with its elegant and British design.
  • Without Cushioning: The B17 Saddle is manufactured using vegetable tan leather. Therefore, it does not need any type of cushioning. As a result, it keeps the saddle cool even in hot weather.
  • Highly Durable: The B17 Saddle will last for a long time on your bike. Of Course, it needs to be taken care of correctly. It also comes with highly durable steel rails and rivets.
  • Comfortable: Even without any type of cushioning, the saddle is very comfortable after it properly breaks in. It also offers support for your sit bones.
  • Bag Loops: This saddle comes with a handle at the rear where you can attach a traditional English-style touring bag. This is very useful when you go for long-distance rides.
  • Color: The B17 Saddle is available in a variety of colors including antique brown, black, honey, and aged tan colors.

Some Weaknesses
  • The B17 Saddle needs quite a long time for it to break in properly.
  • The leather top of the saddle needs high maintenance and regular care.

 

Brooks England’s B17 leather-made saddle is of very high quality and design. It is the perfect choice for trekking, mountain biking, and most importantly long distance sports touring. This is a great looking saddle that will certainly make your bicycle unique. It is already quite comfortable for riding and gets even better after breaking in. The B17 is one of the most popular and oldest models of Brooks England. It is quite wide as it measures just about 170 mm while a regular mountain or road bicycle saddle measures about 140mm. If your sit bones are wider in size or you have an average build, then the B17 is perfect for you. So if you are on the lookout for a brand new bike seat that will meet your commuting needs, then you should buy this British style Brooks B17!

Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle

Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle

2. Selle SMP TRK seat 

SMP Vacuum Technology, Excellent Padding, High Strength | Overall Best Choice

Selle SMP TRK Medium Saddle
  • Best For: Touring, Trekking, City Riding
  • Gender: Unisex
  • Saddle Cover Material: SVT Velvet Touch
  • Cushioning Material: Polyurethane
  • Rail Material: FeC30 Steel Rails
  • Dimensions: 11.02” x 6.30” x 2.95”
  • Weight: 405 grams

Features & Considerations
  • SMP Vacuum Technology: This saddle is built using an innovative production procedure that was introduced by SMP. It enables them to apply the cover on the saddle without using any type of adhesives or mechanical fasteners.
  • Excellent Padding: The soft polyurethane padding on the saddle comes with very high mechanical strength and also provides comfort.
  • High Strength: The saddle body is built well and designed to overcome any kind of resistance over time. Therefore, it is highly durable. Also, the rails offer great resistance to stress and vibration absorption capacity.
  • Cut-out Section: The saddle consists of a cut-out section. This relieves any sort of pressure on the perennial area of the rider, prevents injury, and allows the rider to enjoy a comfortable ride.
  • Color: This amazing saddle is available in black, white, brown MM, red, yellow, green IT, green, light blue, and blue.
  • Warranty: The company provides a warranty of 2 years along with the purchase of this product.

Some Weaknesses
  • It is a comfortable saddle but when riding in the hills for more than 2h+, you’ll feel a little numb as it is not hard enough.

 

The Selle SMP TRK medium-sized saddle is the best choice for a new saddle especially if you are into touring, trekking, and city bike riding. Installing this saddle is very easy and can be done very quickly. And once it breaks in, it becomes the most comfortable saddle that you will ever use. It’s a very firm saddle and you will feel no pressure while riding on your bike. The cover appears to be quite sturdy and you can rest assured that you won’t be sliding around on the saddle. The saddle design, along with the thick padding and large cut-out has made an extremely comfortable ride. So if you are looking for a new saddle that will aid you in reaching your cycling goals, then this one is the right saddle for you!

Selle SMP TRK Medium Saddle

Selle SMP TRK Medium Saddle

3. Terry 2019 Women’s Butterfly saddle

Comfortable Design, Great for Long Rides, Excellent Rails | Premium Choice for Women’s Commuting

Terry 2019 Women's Butterfly Ti Gel + Bicycle Saddle
  • Best For: Road & City Riding
  • Gender: Women
  • Saddle Type: Performance Saddle
  • Saddle Cover Material: Leather With Perforated Butterfly Pattern
  • Cushioning Material: Foam, Gel
  • Rail Material: Ti-316 Rails
  • Dimensions: 10.3” x 6.1” x 2.95”
  • Weight: 255 grams

Features & Considerations
  • For Women: The Terry 2019 Women’s Butterfly Ti Gel + Bicycle Saddle is designed by women for women.
  • Comfortable Design: This saddle is much wider and also flatter compared to sport saddles. This especially the case for the rear side. This design is also great for the sit bones. Also, the Italian leather cover is perforated in a butterfly design.
  • Cut-out Section: The cut-out section is very wide. It runs all the way from the nose straight to the midsection. This ensures flexibility for the rider and also helps to reduce pressure.
  • Longer Rides: This seat is great for longer rides like a very slim gel layer of padding is applied at the top of the saddle which gets rid of any type of pressure.
  • Excellent Rails: The saddle is equipped with Ti-316 which are titanium rails. These are exceptionally lightweight while also being very strong.
  • Color: This amazing saddle is available only in Black.
  • Warranty: Terry saddles are guaranteed for twenty-four months from the date of purchase. A faulty product will be repaired or replaced by Terry within the warranty time frame.

Some Weaknesses
  • The center cut out of this Terry saddle is wider than that of previous models.

 

The Terry 2019 Women’s Butterfly is an excellent choice if you want to upgrade your old saddle. The cut-out section is very wide and there is extra gel placed at the top of the saddle. These are the main features that help to differentiate between this model and the classic Butterfly. The wider cutout, the outlined rear, and the thin layer of gel padding allow this saddle to provide maximum comfort and durability.

Like all Butterflies, the Ti Gel + shares the basic construction characteristics. It’s wider in the rear than typical race saddles for good support of a woman’s sit bones. The top is flat and low profile, and we’ve used the ideal blend of stiffness and softness in the foam which is injection molded to allow for good support and power while pedaling. Outfitted with lightweight Ti rails and made by hand in Italy. This is a great saddle for women and is widely popular in the community for its performance and comfort.

Related: Top Women’s Road Bike Saddles Reviews

Terry 2019 Women's Butterfly Ti Gel + Bicycle Saddle

Terry 2019 Women’s Butterfly Ti Gel + Bicycle Saddle

4. Fabric Scoop Pro seat

Lightweight, Excellent Padding, Waterproof | Premium choice for Men’s Commuting

Fabric Scoop Pro Saddle
  • Best For: Commuting, Cross-Country, Cyclocross, Gravel, Road
  • Gender: Unisex
  • Saddle Type: Performance Saddle
  • Saddle Cover Material: Nylon Cover
  • Cushioning Material: PU Foam
  • Rail Material: Carbon Fiber Rails
  • Dimensions: 11.10” x 5.59”
  • Weight: 192 grams

Features & Considerations
  • Lightweight: The flexible nylon base is equal parts lightweight and comfortable. Also, the rails made of carbon fiber shed weight while boosting strength.
  • Excellent Padding: The dense polyurethane foam cushions your sit bone on very rough terrain. Thus, making it easier for you to ride no matter how tough the terrain gets.
  • Waterproof: This saddle comes with waterproof microfiber shell fabric that keeps it dry and also allows it to be cleaned easily.
  • Versatile: Like most of the bicycle saddles produced today, this Fabric saddle is built to suit most types of riding including mountain biking, cyclocross, and also road biking.
  • Color: The Fabric Scoop Pro Saddle is available only in Black and Black/Red.
  • Warranty: All Fabric products will be covered for one year from date-of-purchase against issues arising from manufacturing defects and faults.

Some Weaknesses
  • Great saddle but it does not look as good for the price!

 

The Fabric Scoop Pro is one of the best saddles out there right now. The Scoop offers you different alternatives according to your riding style, body fit, and overall riding feel. You will be provided with the option to choose either a saddle made up of carbon fiber or nylon. If you choose to go with nylon, your saddle will be both comfortable and lightweight. That is not all. There is more. The saddle also comes with different types of rail materials. This Pro version is equipped with the brand’s 9mm rails which are oval in shape and made up of carbon fiber. These rails are the stiffest and lightest of them all. This saddle also has versions of different shapes. You can choose your favorite one of three shapes. The shapes are Radius, Shallow, & Flat. You should choose the shape that you feel will be best for you and your riding style.

Fabric Scoop Pro Saddle

Fabric Scoop Pro Saddle

5. Brooks England C17 saddle

Naturally Flexible Rubber, Surface Absorption, Highly Comfortable | All Weather Best Choice

Sale
Brooks England C17 Saddle
  • Best For: Commuting, Gravel, Road
  • Gender: Unisex
  • Saddle Cover Material: Vulcanised Natural Rubber and Nylon Top
  • Cushioning Material: None
  • Rail Material: Steel Rail With Black Powder Coating
  • Dimensions: 11.14” x 6.46” x 2.05”
  • Weight: 464 grams

Features & Considerations
  • Naturally Flexible Rubber: The amazing cambium saddles of Brooks England are made from flexible natural rubber that is harvested straight from the trees.
  • Surface Absorption: The Brooks England C17 is designed to absorb shocks while you ride so that it can smooth out the ride for you.
  • Highly Comfortable: This saddle provides natural comfort for the duration of the ride in all conditions, over all-terrain, performing consistently over time and through constant use.
  • Adheres To You: Rubber is a natural substance that reacts to and follows the rider’s movements. So you can say that the saddle actually moves along with you to make sure you are comfortable at all times.
  • Color: The Brooks England C17 is available in Octane, Mud, Orange, and Black.
  • Warranty: This Cambium Saddle is manufactured in Italy and guaranteed against defects in materials or workmanship for 2 years from the date of purchase.

Some Weaknesses
  • The rubber saddle was a bit too grippy than usual. A lot of riders don’t like that.

 

The Brooks England C17 nearly pulls off being a one size fits all saddle with its stylish look, smooth ride, and comfortable profile. And you can wear anything you like when you ride on this saddle. The saddle works well for both Lycra or plain clothes rides and features a nylon-wrapped design that offers many of the same benefits of leather while being able to stand up to all weather conditions. If you’re searching for a good-looking saddle that contours to your underside and helps avoid numbness, the Cambium C17 All Weather from Brooks England is well worth the investment.

Brooks England C17 Saddle

Brooks England C17 Saddle

6. Selle SMP TRK Gel seat

SMP Vacuum Technology, Great Padding, High Strength

Sale
Selle SMP TRK Gel Saddle
  • Best For: Trekking, City, Touring
  • Gender: Unisex
  • Saddle Cover Material: SVT Cover
  • Cushioning Material: Soft Polyurethane + GEL
  • Rail Material: Steel Rails
  • Dimensions: 11.02” x 6.30”
  • Weight: 485 grams

Features & Considerations
  • SMP Vacuum Technology: Selle has its own method of producing these saddles. And this method enables them to apply the saddle cover without the use of any type of adhesives or mechanical fasteners. And this ensures its high quality.
  • Cut-out Section: The Selle SMP TRK Gel Saddle comes with a cut-out section. This prevents the saddle from applying any sort of pressure on the perennial area of the rider.
  • High Strength: The body of the saddle is made in such a way that it has high endurance and can withstand any type of challenge that comes its way. It is made in Italy and is very durable.
  • Rail & Plates: The rails offer great resistance to stress and vibration absorption capacity. Also, the fixing plate is an exclusive structural element that allows for achieving higher standards of security and robustness.
  • Excellent Padding: The soft polyurethane padding on the saddle comes with very high mechanical strength and also provides comfort.
  • Color: The Selle SMP TRK Gel Saddle is only available in black.
  • Warranty: The company provides a warranty of 2 years along with the purchase of this product.

Some Weaknesses
  • The gel of the saddle flattens at the pressure points, to the point where the thin layer, if any, left at those locations provides virtually no benefit.

 

The Selle SMP TRK Gel is the top choice for sport, city, trekking, and touring bike saddles. It comes in highly comfortable padding with additional comfort provided by the self-modeling gel. Therefore, this makes the saddle perfect for all types of terrains. It does take a few miles to break in properly, however, even with that said, it’s much better than most stock saddles. It will prevent you from getting injured due to pressure from the saddle while also making sure that you maintain a good posture. Our testers gave a thumbs up after trying out this saddle. They have ridden on the saddle several times and each time the ride was 20-30 miles and between 1-2 hours and we are very happy to say that they experience no numbness at all. So if you are interested, check this fantastic saddle out today!

Selle SMP TRK Gel Saddle

Selle SMP TRK Gel Saddle

7. Ergon – SM Sport Ergonomic Comfort saddle

Optimum Shape, Orthopedic Foam, Relief Channel

Ergon - SM Sport Ergonomic Comfort Bicycle Saddle
  • Best For: Mountain Biking
  • Gender: Men
  • Saddle Cover Material: Microfiber Cover
  • Cushioning Material: Orthopedic Comfort Foam
  • Rail Material: Chromoly Rails
  • Dimensions: 10.59” x 6.30”
  • Weight: 305 grams

Features & Considerations
  • Relief Channel: The anatomically optimized relief channel is specifically designed for men to eliminate pressure, numbness, and pain in the perineum and genital areas.
  • Optimum Shape: This saddle consists of a flattened rear and a Y-shape that helps to ensure freedom of movement for the rider.
  • Orthopedic Foam: It also comes with orthopedic comfort foam that helps to provide excellent comfort.
  • Exceptional Materials: The microfiber cover, nylon composite shell, and CroMo saddle rails offer a rigid structure and excellent durability.
  • Color: The Ergon – SM Sport Bicycle Saddle is available only in Black.
  • Warranty: Ergon provides a limited 2-Year warranty against defects in materials and workmanship.

Some Weaknesses
  • While reasonably comfortable with those who have wide sit bones, this thing creaks like there is no tomorrow. All of the creakings occurs where the rail insert touches the plastic seat frame.

 

When it comes to riding comfort, nothing is quite as nice as a properly fitted saddle that is designed for your style of riding. If you typically sit upright while riding, then you’ll want to steer away from a saddle that is designed for aggressive road riding, and vice versa. The Ergon SM Sport is an MTB saddle that is great for touring, trails, and all-mountain riding. Our testers claimed that this saddle is excellent for long rides. It will cause you no discomfort when you are riding for hours and will certainly leave you satisfied. This is because of the saddle’s ergonomics. The saddle does not turn soft or give out no matter how long you sit on it. It is highly recommended by both our testing team and also other riders who have used it. So if you want high comfort and relieving pressure, go for this one today!

Ergon - SM Sport Ergonomic Comfort Bicycle Saddle

Ergon – SM Sport Ergonomic Comfort Bicycle Saddle

8. Ergon – SFC3 Ergonomic Comfort seat

Excellent Cushioning, Relief Channel, Reduced Pressure

Ergon - SFC3 Ergonomic Comfort Bicycle Saddle
  • Best For: Fitness, E-Bike, Sport, Touring, Commuting
  • Gender: Unisex
  • Saddle Type: Cushioned Saddle
  • Saddle Cover Material: Microfiber Cover
  • Cushioning Material: Orthopedic Comfort Foam + Gel Pads
  • Rail Material: Steel Rails
  • Dimensions: 13.25” x 7.5” x 2.25”
  • Weight: 395 grams

Features & Considerations
  • Less Pressure: Large seating surface of this saddle distributes the pressure on the sit bones and pubic bones, ultimately reducing potential numbness.
  • Relief Channel: Ergonomic testing and the latest pressure-measurement technology lead to the optimal position of the relief channel.
  • Excellent Cushioning: The saddle consists of added gel pads that provide extra cushioning and comfort for the rider.
  • Steel Rails: The rails are made up of light FeC steel that allows it to remain sturdy when you ride through rough and tough roads or mountain terrains. It also allows it to be very durable.
  • Color: The Ergon – SFC3 Bicycle Saddle is available only in Black.
  • Warranty: Ergon provides a limited 2-Year warranty against defects in materials and workmanship.

Some Weaknesses
  • The Ergon – SFC3 Bicycle Saddle is quite heavy compared to its competitors.

 

A comfortable saddle means you will spend more time on your bike doing what you love. The Ergon SFC3 features pressure-free comfort for fitness bikes, e-bikes, and touring bikes. It is surprisingly comfortable despite having such a thin profile. It does not snag or pull clothing be it of any type and wide enough for longer fun and enjoyment. You can ride with this saddle without having to wear padded cycling shorts. Also, it is great for anyone with larger sit bones. So if you feel this is the right choice for you, get them as soon as possible!

Ergon - SFC3 Ergonomic Comfort Bicycle Saddle

Ergon – SFC3 Ergonomic Comfort Bicycle Saddle

9. Fizik Antares R3 Versus EVO saddle

Excellent Power Transfer, Great Cushioning, Flexibility & Support

Fizik Antares R3 Versus EVO Saddle
  • Best For: Road Biking
  • Gender: Unisex
  • Saddle Type: Cushioned Saddle
  • Saddle Cover Material: Light Microtex Cover
  • Cushioning Material: Comfort Core Foam
  • Rail Material: Alloy Rails
  • Dimensions: 10.83” x 5.59”
  • Weight: 215 grams

Features & Considerations
  • Flexibility & Support: This tremendous saddle is built for riders that have reduced pelvic rotation and average body flexibility when you are riding your bike. This profile of the saddle provides immense support and versatility for you so that you can get your perfect spot.
  • Great Cushioning: This Fizik saddle comes with a comfort core foam layer under the very durable Microtex saddle cover which offers excellent cushioning.
  • Comfort Channel: It also has a full-length comfort channel that reduces pressure on your soft tissues and spreads your weight across the whole saddle for optimum comfort.
  • Power Transfer: The nylon shell which is composite carbon-reinforced also includes the Wing Flex technology, provides a lot of flexibility at the point where the saddle touches your thighs. This helps to maintain responsive power transfer.
  • Easy Maintenance: The microtex saddle cover is also very easy to clean and therefore it helps to protect the saddle’s internal part.
  • Color: This Fizik Saddle is available only in Black.
  • Warranty: Fizik provides a warranty of 2 years along with the purchase of this saddle.

Some Weaknesses
  • There’s a slight gap between the bottom and cushion on the saddle.

 

The Fizik Antares R3 Versus EVO is the best saddle for you if you like to change things around sometimes and shift about on your saddle while you ride.
It comes with a fairly flat profile and very comfortable padding. It is quite flexible and allows you to move about however you want, forward or backward and even from one side to the other. It is quite sturdy, however, not too much. It strikes the perfect balance in that way. This is due to the carbon-reinforced shell which will enable you to have better control while also ensuring that the road vibrations are reduced. Also, the shell’s wings provide the ideal amount of flex to make sure you feel as comfortable as possible.
The relief channel is great. The fact that it doesn’t have a full cut-out section is a nice touch as you will find some extra stiffness that will help you during your fast descents. So if you think that this saddle is a great match for you, get it right away!

Fizik Antares R3 Versus EVO Saddle

Fizik Antares R3 Versus EVO Saddle

10. Selle Royal Respiro Soft Athletic seat

Royal Gel, Central Cut-Out, Water-Resistant

Selle Royal Respiro Soft Athletic Bike Saddle
  • Best For: Recreational Riding
  • Gender: Unisex
  • Saddle Type: Cushioned Saddle
  • Saddle Cover Material: Synthetic Cover
  • Cushioning Material: Gel Padding
  • Rail Material: Steel Rails
  • Dimensions: 10.9” x 6.4”
  • Weight: 429 grams

Features & Considerations
  • Central Cut-Out: The central cut-out of the saddle helps to distribute weight and relieve pressure on sensitive areas. The front ventilation channel moves cooling air along with the cut-out.
  • Royal Gel: The Royal Gel adapts to your anatomy, reduces pressure points, and helps absorb vibration and shock for comfort. The gel does not age, harden, or migrate over time.
  • Water-Resistant: Royal Vacuum Light is a patented Selle Royal technology that allows the saddle to be 100% sealed and therefore water-resistant.
  • Saddle Cover: The saddle cover is designed to stay cooler in the sun, helping prevent your backside from getting scorched when you remount after an off-bike stroll or errand.
  • Saddle Profile: The Respiro Athletic saddle shape is designed to offer support and comfort for those riding in a slightly bent forward riding position.
  • Attach Your Bag: It consists of an integrated clip system that allows for hassle-free attachment of a compatible saddlebag. Please note that the package does not include a saddlebag.
  • Color: The Selle Royal Respiro Soft Athletic Bike Saddle is available in Black.
  • Warranty: Selle Royal provides a warranty of 1 year which is applicable from the date of purchase.

Some Weaknesses
  • If the saddle gets wet from rain or some other source, the water gets trapped in the net inlay of the saddle, and it takes longer than the rest of the saddle to dry.

 

The Selle Royal Respiro Soft Athletic is one of the most comfortable saddles out there. It offers some fantastic features to help you improve your performance and maintain its durability. Our testing team had a lot of good things to say about this product. It features a narrow profile which will help you to avoid the chafing that comes with wider saddles. Also, it stays really cool so you won’t feel uncomfortable if you are going for a long ride on a hot day. Also, it is quite good looking and will make your bike even more attractive. The saddle being water-resistant is a huge bonus and you will be happy to know that it does not feel slippery even when it is wet. So do you want to ride feeling comfortable and in total control? Then hurry up and buy this saddle today!

Selle Royal Respiro Soft Athletic Bike Saddle

Selle Royal Respiro Soft Athletic Bike Saddle

11. Selle Royal Scientia saddle

3D Skin Gel, Curva Suspension, Body Contour

Selle Royal Scientia Relaxed Saddle
  • Best For: Road Biking
  • Gender: Unisex
  • Saddle Type: Cushioned Saddle
  • Saddle Cover Material: Synthetic Cover
  • Cushioning Material: 3D Skin Gel
  • Rail Material: Steel Rails
  • Dimensions: 11.38” x 8.82”
  • Weight: 520 grams

Features & Considerations
  • 3D Skin Gel: The Royal Gel is applied precisely at crucial points of contact on the surface of the saddle. This allows it to provide better shock absorption and lower the total weight of the saddle.
  • Curva Suspension: The saddle comes with an exclusive curved suspension design at the back of the base. This provides the utmost comfort by preventing pressure from being applied to contact points of the seat bone area. It also offers extra lateral flexibility.
  • Central Reservoir: There are indentations on the center of the saddle’s surface that have been designed to provide even more comfort for the rider.
  • Rear Plateau: The saddle has an elevated rear area. This helps to ensure that you don’t slip backward while riding and also reduces pressure at the center of the saddle to prevent discomfort.
  • Body Contour: This saddle features a design specific to its radius. This makes it perfect for differing spin angles. Therefore, the more inclined the riding position is, the smaller the edge-radius will be.
  • Color: The Selle Royal Scientia Relaxed Saddle is available only in Black
  • Warranty: Selle Royal provides a warranty of 1 year which is applicable from the date of purchase.

Some Weaknesses
  • The saddle is a bit too narrow and hard for some riders.

 

The Selle Royal Scientia is a very well built saddle that primarily focuses on comfort for the rider. It is a personalized saddle for riders who enjoy riding in a relaxed position. Here, the space between the ischial bones surpasses 13 cm. Our testers claimed that this is by far the most comfortable bike saddle they have ever used! It’s wide and padded enough in the back to alleviate pressure when you sit upright but narrow and recessed enough in the front to be comfortable riding in the athletic position. Also, as Selle Royal emphasized so much on comfort, you will not feel any sort of discomfort even after riding for more than 2 hours. It is built for use on road bikes but we have seen users even set them up on their spin bikes. So hurry up and get yours today!

Selle Royal Scientia Relaxed Saddle

Selle Royal Scientia Relaxed Saddle

12. Fabric Scoop Sport Radius seat

Innovative Design, Radius Profile, Flexible & Durable

Fabric Scoop Sport Radius Gel Saddle
  • Best For: Great For All Types Of Cycling
  • Gender: Unisex
  • Saddle Type: Cushioned Saddle
  • Saddle Cover Material: Microfiber Cover
  • Cushioning Material: Gel Cushioning
  • Rail Material: Steel Rails
  • Dimensions: 10.24” x 6.10”
  • Weight: 374 grams

Features & Considerations
  • Innovative Design: The Fabric Scoop Sport saddle design provides comfort for every ride. The distinctive three-segment construction gets rid of the overall tension that is found in the usual hard and stretched saddles.
  • Radius Profile: The Radius profile has the roundest shape through the rear section and maximum padding. It is designed for an upright riding position.
  • Gel Padding: This saddle comes with very soft gel padding. This gel helps to distribute your weight uniformly over the saddle surface. This triple gel combined with the low-density foam and the saddle’s Radius profile ensures great comfort and support.
  • Flexible & Durable: The design of this saddle coupled with the bonded cover allows it to be cleaned very easily. Therefore, it also allows it to be very durable.
  • Color: The Fabric Scoop Sport Radius Gel Saddle is available only in Black.
  • Warranty: All Fabric products will be covered for one year from date-of-purchase against issues arising from manufacturing defects and faults.

Some Weaknesses
  • The design of the saddle is a little too minimalistic.

 

The Fabric Scoop Sport Radius Gel Saddle is definitely worth the money! It is a stiff and reasonably priced bicycle saddle that will surely make it worth your while.
Our testers really praised the construction and design of this saddle. The radius certainly supports your backside much better and the gel inserts help you forget that you’re even on a saddle. It looks very nice and seems hard for gel at first but after riding longer you can tell it doesn’t get in the way. Also, another great feature of this saddle is that it is neither too bulky nor too thin. It is exactly the perfect shape and size. If you are tired of trying out saddles that feel uncomfortable and frankly just don’t get the job done, you should definitely give this saddle a shot!

Fabric Scoop Sport Radius Gel Saddle

Fabric Scoop Sport Radius Gel Saddle


Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. Is a wide bicycle saddle more comfortable?

Ans.: A common misconception that a lot of people in the cycling community have is that a wide bicycle saddle is much more comfortable than a narrow one. Actually which one is more comfortable completely depends on what type of riding you do. Of course, cool-looking saddles made for racing do not seem comfortable at the first glance. However, wider saddles generate more friction and cause chafing when you ride it frequently. Therefore, if you ride or pedal a lot, you should go for a thinner saddle.

Q2. Are gel bike seats good for commuting?

Ans.: Gel padding is the top choice for most bike commuters as it provides a soft, shock-absorbing feel beneath your sit bones. Gel padding conforms to your sit bones to offer the maximum surface area that supports your shape & weight, unlike foam padding.

Q3. How long does a bike saddle last?

Ans.: Well, to be honest, that completely depends on how often you ride your bike. However, that does not change the fact that the gel or foam padding breaks down over the years of its usage. With that being said, all bicycle saddle manufacturers recommend replacing your saddle at a minimum every 2 years.

Q4. How to take care of leather saddles?

Ans.: First of all, do not leave your leather saddle idle. You should use it as much as possible. Doing that will enable it to break in faster. Second of all, treat your leather with the correct proofide. Otherwise, moisture, water, or any type of cracks will cause damage to your leather saddle. So treat it with the proofide suggested by the manufacturer of the saddle. To learn more about how to take care of your saddles properly, check out the video below:

BROOKS ENGLAND - Leather Saddle Maintenance & Care

Conclusion

We hope this article has helped you make a more informed decision and has added value to your cycling life. If you feel that looking for a new bike seat for commuting is too time-consuming, please feel free to choose one from our selection. Trust us when we say that it will be completely worth your while. We wish you all the best! Have fun with your brand new saddle. Thank you for reading this article. Take care!

My name is Dion Lewis. I’ve been cycling since my childhood. When I was in high school, I started racing in our local competitions. In my college life, I took a part-time job in a bicycle shop and I learned how to repair and maintain bicycles professionally. Though I love racing, mountain biking is another thing I do frequently. My friends, neighbors, and colleagues treat me as an avid rider and take my suggestions while they plan for a new bike or bike gear.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a Comment

      ApexBikes
      Logo