Disclosure: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, but this never influences our opinion.

8 Best Brooks Saddles for Commuting (Reviewed Sep, 2020)

In this article, we are going to give you a rundown of the best brook saddles for your regular/heavy commuting to make your choice easier. But before we delve in, let’s get to know why you need the right saddle for your bike. The kind of saddle you choose will greatly influence the quality of your rides. Your saddle choice will determine how comfortable you feel while riding your bike, and how long your ride will take. The truth is, you can’t ride for a long time if you’re not comfortable. With that in mind, here is a rundown of the six best Brooks saddles for your regular/ heavy commuting.

8 best Brooks saddles you can buy today for commuting

We have chosen the following Brooks Saddles based on your physical structure, your riding position, your commuting type, and the saddle type. I hope you will find this list helpful and get your suitable Brooks saddle.

1) Brooks England B17 (for men)

Brooks England B17 (for men)

This saddle will best suit:

Rider’s Weight: Regular

Riding Position: Upright & relaxed

Commuting Type: Regular

Saddle Type: Regular. No Spring Saddle

Weight: 520 gm, Height: 65 mm, Length: 275 mm, Width: 175 mm

Why is this the most recommended Brooks saddle?

  • The flagship model of Brooks. Made with 100 years’ of the traditional method. No. 1 choice for regular long or short distance commuter.
  • It comes in different colors and variations. You can even change the rails if you have money to spare.
  • You’ll never get rid of this saddle as it is the original handmade leather saddle.
  • Rails are generally made of Steel, Titanium or Copper, making it strong and durable.
  • Offers hand-hammered Copper rivets.
  • It comes with a 2-year warranty, and a 10-year extended warranty is given to those who register it on the Brooks Company website.
  • Light-weighted, only 540 grams.
  • It comes with a maintenance kit and a waterproof saddle cover.
  • Features micro-adjust seat posts.
  • Fairly easy to look after and maintain.

Drawbacks:

  • It’s a good idea to buy a Proofide (Brooks’ leather conditioner) as the bike seat is not waterproof.
  • Takes around 200 – 300 miles of riding on it for perfect “Breaking-in”.
  • Adjustment bolts are tight.
  • Excessive price.

The saddles cover is made of full-grain leather that will mold to your shape, as well as your riding style in just a month of use, according to your complete comfort and durability. The full-grain leather cover also keeps the saddle warm, especially during warm weather. The saddle top features three holes to provide you with natural ventilation where it’s most needed. It comes with standard steel rivets to hold the leather skin to the steel base, standard steel rails underneath it to absorb shock and minimize vibrations on rough roads, as well as two standard back loops to attach your bag. It also features an abrupt taper between the nose sections and the rear, which helps prevent inner thigh-rubbing and chaffing. However, it lacks two rear springs, which are common with the B66 and B67 models.

2) Brooks England B17 Short (for women)

2) B17 Short (for women)

This saddle will best suit:

Rider’s Weight: Regular

Riding Position: Upright & relaxed

Commuting Types: Regular

Saddle Type: Regular No Spring Saddle

Weight: 460 gm, Height: 58 mm, Length: 242 mm, Width: 176 mm

The female version of Brooks’ Flagship B17 Model:

  • It’s slim, broader is shaped and has a short nose which makes it one of the best seats for women.
  • Unbelievably comfortable during commutes, thanks to its soft HANDMADE LEATHER made in England.
  • A FLAGSHIP Model from Brooks. Has been selling in the market for over 100 years.
  • Will adjust to your shape and riding style in just a month.
  • It will outlast your riding career and gives you a lifetime comfort.
  • A 10-year extended warranty is given to those who register it on the Brooks Company website.
  • It comes in different colors (Honey, brown, and black).

Drawbacks:

  • Not waterproof, the seat will literally deform when exposed to rain.
  • Higher buying price.

The B17 Short saddle is made of the finest vegetable-tanned leather. It’ shorter, broader construction and soft vegetable tanned leather make it incredibly comfortable, which is why it’s ideal for commuting. It features three holes at the top to provide natural ventilation where it matters the most. The saddle also features standard hand-hammered steel rivets to hold the leather skin to the steel base, standard steel rails underneath it to absorb shock and minimize vibrations on rough roads, as well as two standard back loops to attach your bag. Most riders say that they broke in the lather saddle after just 300 miles of riding. It’s slim, wider shape, and short nose makes it ideal for commuting. It weighs 574 grams. The B17 short comes with accessories, such as a 13mm spanner to adjust the tension of the leather, maintenance, and warranty information manual, waterproof saddle cover to prevent contact with water. One notable thing is that it doesn’t feature rear springs like the B66 and B67 models.

3) Brooks England B67 (for Men)

B67 (for Men)

This saddle will best suit:

Rider’s Weight: Weight between regular and plus size

Riding Position: Upright & relaxed

Commuting Types: Regular/Heavy Commuting

Saddle Type: Sprung Saddle

Weight: 850 gm, Height: 73 mm, Length: 260 mm, Width: 205 mm

Another best saddle for Men:

  • It offers extreme comfort and control for finely aged leather when it breaks in after a couple of rides (between 150 to 800 kilometers).
  • It comes with a two-year warranty, and a 10-year warranty is awarded who registers the product with the company website.
  • Rails are attached to a micro-adjust seat pillar similar to you can find in the B17 model.
  • The seat offers classically sprung for supreme comfort.
  • A long-lasting saddle for its handmade leather.
  • It comes with a tension wrench.

Drawbacks:

  • Creaky springs can be the loudest part of the bike sometimes.
  • Leather can be slick, rock hard if not properly broken in.
  • Expensive like most of the Brooks saddles.
  • Have to keep it in cover as it is not waterproof.
  • Weighs around 850g, so it’s a little heavy.

 

B67 Saddle is made of finely aged leather using old traditional techniques. Combine that with the two classical rear springs, and you get an incredibly comfortable saddle that is ideal for commuting. The two coil springs on the rear also help to absorb large shocks and minimize vibrations when riding on rough roads. The three large holes at the top of the saddle provide natural ventilation to the rider and keep them cool throughout the ride. It comes with an all-black steel frame, stainless steel rivets that hold the leather skin to the steel base, and single rails that easily attach to modern seat posts.

4) Brooks England B67 SOFTENED SHORT (for Women)

B67 SOFTENED SHORT (for Women)

This saddle will best suit:

Rider’s Weight: Weight between regular and plus size

Riding Position: Upright & relaxed

Commuting Types: Regular/Heavy Commuting

Saddle Type: Sprung Saddle with no break-in period. Comfortable from day 1.

Weight: 820 gm, Height: 58 mm, Length: 240 mm, Width: 205 mm

Another best saddle for Women:

  • A short and thick saddle to comfortably fit the body of a female rider.
  • Made with the finest vegetable tanned leather, it helps shorten the long break-in period.
  • Ideal for women who like to ride with their bike’s handlebars a little bit higher than the saddle.
  • Natural ventilation adds more comfort for female riders.
  • A great choice for older women.
  • It comes with accessories and waterproof saddle cover.

Drawbacks:

  • Expensive as usual.
  • Not for riders who want a cushy saddle.
  • Not waterproof, have to use the waterproof saddle cover.
  • It requires much care. You need to apply Proofide on it once in a few weeks.

 

The B67 Softened Short Saddle comes with the following dimension: weight (810g, height (85mm), width (205mm), and length (240 mm). It’s made of the finest vegetable-tanned leather, giving it an incredibly soft feel while reading. It’s no wonder that it’s the most preferred saddle for commuting. The tubular steel rivets attach the leather skin to the steel base. The frame is made of all black steel to guarantee strength and durability. The single rails make it compatible with modern micro-adjust seat posts. The two coil springs on the rear offer extra suspension, absorb large shocks, and minimizes vibrations, giving the rider a smooth riding experience even on uneven surfaces. The three holes on the saddle provide ventilation where it’s needed the most.

5) Brooks England B135 (for Men)

B135 (for Men)

This saddle will best suit:

Rider’s Weight: Plus Size Riders

Riding Position: Upright & relaxed

Commuting Types: Regular

Saddle Type: Heavily sprung saddle

Weight: 1630 gm, Height: 117 mm, Length: 289 mm, Width: 205 mm

Reasons why you want a classically designed saddle:

  • Features double rear coil springs and double loop front springs make it ideal for heavy riders.
  • The design of the seat shape is inspired by the classic “B66”.
  • Rivets are made of 100% tubular steel escorting aluminum finish.
  • Unisex, good for both men and women.
  • Adapts various bicycles like Tandem bikes.
  • It comes with a 2-year warranty and a 10-year warranty extension for buyers who register the product on the company website.

Drawbacks:

  • The stoker gives surprising bumps in the road depending on the weather.
  • Has a very upright riding position.
  • It’s quite expensive (Retails for $179 on Amazon).
  • Heavier than the other models in its range.
  • Not waterproof.

The saddle top is made of the finest vegetable-tanned leather, making it extremely comfortable while riding. It’s no wonder that people who commute a lot love it. It’s double sprung, which means it features two coil springs at the rear, as well as a two-loop spring at the front for maximum suspension. The coil springs offer the extra saddle suspension and absorb large shocks when riding on uneven roads, giving the rider a smooth riding experience. It features double steel rails that make it strong and durable and fits in modern micro seat posts. The three holes on the saddle provide the necessary ventilation for the rider. The Brooks B-135 Saddle also features tubular steel rivets to hold the leather skin to the steel base.

6) Brooks England B33 (for Men)

B33 (for Men)

This saddle will best suit:

Rider’s Weight: Plus Size Riders

Riding Position: Upright & relaxed

Commuting Types: Heavy Commuting

Saddle Type: Heavily sprung saddle

Weight: 1600 gm, Height: 110 mm, Length: 318 mm, Width: 235 mm

Choose this if you want a strong saddle:

  • A HEAVY DUTY saddle for heavy commuters which features double rear coil springs and a double loop front spring.
  • Maintaining the original design all the way from 1938.
  • Stainless steel and double rail design guarantee its strength and durability.
  • Made with vegetable-tanned leather which is handmade.
  • It comes with a 2-year warranty and a 10-year warranty extension for those who register the product on the company website.

Drawbacks:

  • Chrome falls off the coil, poor quality peeling.
  • Not thick padded.
  • A little bit weighty.
  • Not waterproof.
  • The buying price is high.

Made from the finest vegetable tanned leather, which means it’s soft enough to give riders a comfortable riding experience. Combine that with the broad embossed leather top that provides more room for your bum cheeks to rest, and you understand why It’s a great saddle for commuting. It also features a double loop front spring, as well as a double rear coil spring for extra suspension and for absorbing large shocks when riding on pothole-ridden roads. It’s heavy-duty, which is why it’s ideal for heavy commuters. Its featured chrome-plated steel rail design for extra strength and compatibility with modern seat posts. The tubular steel rivets hold the leather skin to the steel base. The holes of the vegetable-tanned leather provide ventilation where it’s required the most.

7) Brooks England C19 All Weather (for Men)

C19 All Weather (for Men)

This saddle will best suit:

Rider’s Weight: Regular

Riding Position: Upright & relaxed

Commuting Types: Regular

Saddle Type: Cambium saddle with no break-in period. Comfortable from day 1.

Weight: 490 gm, Height: 57 mm, Length: 275 mm, Width: 184 mm

A saddle for all conditions:

  • The cover is made from waterproof nylon, works flawlessly in all conditions.
  • Pepful of fiberglass backplate that can carry a saddle bag or other necessary things.
  • Vulcanized natural rubber and Organic cotton canvas add excellent resilience.
  • Riders can also select the carved version for their own perspective.
  • Modern and slender looking.

Drawbacks:

  • The front is comparatively narrow, not a wide saddle.
  • Not the best choice for a big cyclist.
  • Not so cushy, so it might hurt sit bones.
  • Nylon made rubber can be pretty It can be a disaster for some riders.
  • Longer break-in time.

The Cambium All Weather C19 saddle is a modern and sporty looking saddle made from waterproof nylon, works just absolutely flawless in all conditions, to be more specific in all-weather conditions. Made from vulcanized natural rubber and Organic cotton canvas adds more resilience provided by the structural textile on bumpy roads. The backplate of the saddle is updated with fiberglass that loops for a saddle bag or other accessories. With the same contemporary design of the Brooks Cambium range, the All Weather C19 is a durable and comfortable saddle that is always prepared for a ride in all situations. This saddle also comes with a center cutout that is the “C19 Carved” version.

8) Brooks England Swallow (Sportier Version for Road Bike Commuting)

Swallow (Sportier Version for Road Bike Commuting)

This saddle will best suit:

Rider’s Weight: Regular

Riding Position: Upright & relaxed

Commuting Types: Commuting with road bikes

Saddle Type: Regular. No Spring Saddle

Weight: 490 gm, Height: 62 mm, Length: 285 mm, Width: 153 mm

A great fit for road/MTB:

  • This elastic handmade leathered saddle is the perfect choice for road/MTB.
  • It offers varieties of colors.
  • Rivets are made of 100% tubular steel.
  • Timeless design.
  • A reliable choice for long-distance riders.

Drawbacks:

  • An overpriced saddle.
  • Need proper maintenance from time to time.
  • A bit heavier saddle.
  • The break-in period is longer.
  • The bolts barely adjust the saddle tension.

 

The B15 Swallow is a classic looking saddle for the classic racer, holding its traditional design which is a timeless design widely regarded as the precursor of all modern racing saddles. The saddle was a popular choice among the professional cyclists competing in the various tours and stage races. Handmade in England- manufactured with the 100-year-old traditional technology following the same Patent principle since 1937. The whole frame is chrome plated which makes it a reliable choice for road/MTB as well as for long-distance rides. There are 2 versions of this saddle and one of the features original chromium-plated steel metalwork and one featuring much lighter titanium metalwork.

Misconceptions about breaking-in of leather saddles

Many bikes ride like leather saddles because they are handmade in a classic style using old-world techniques. That means they fit well with modern bikes. Leather saddles are fairly strong and firm when new and can create a little discomfort for the rider. That’s why leather saddle buyers inquire about the break-in period before they buy. While most riders agree that leather saddles need time to break in, they know that the quicker the leather breaks in, the quicker it will conform to their body shape and riding styles, which enhance their riding experience. However, there is a lot of misconception out there about the period it takes for a leather saddle to break in. Some say it takes at least 1000 km to break in, while others say it takes months.

The truth is that the time it takes to break in a leather saddle varies considerably. For example, the time it takes to break in a Brooks leather saddle depends on the amount of heat, moisture, pressure, and time. It would only take 200 km (about two days) to break in a Brooks Leather saddle when riding in hot conditions. The results are different in cold conditions. For example, you can ride for 1500 miles during winter, but the leather saddle won’t a break-in. In fact, just two forty-mile rides in June, when there is a mini heat-wave, would cause your Brooks leather saddle to break-in quicker than riding the entire winter. Also, your Brooks leather saddles will break in quickly if you rub in the Brooks Proofide and polish it after every ride. Proofide is made of natural ingredients that condition, rainproof, and preserve leather saddles. The break-in period will also depend on what you are breaking in a Brooks leather saddle. Breaking in a lather saddle to fit your sit bones will take a shorter time because your sit bones are hard and will accelerate the process. On the other hand, breaking in a leather saddle to fit your soft tissues will take a bit longer because they are soft.

Ideal Saddles for commuting

The saddle is a vital component of your bicycle. That’s because it bears most of your weight on the bike. Not to mention that it’s one of the bike’s components that comes into contact with your body, which it’s a vital point of control. The wrong saddle can cause friction and discomfort, ruining your riding experience. Therefore, it’s important to choose one that fits both your body shape and riding style. Most saddles out there are not designed to fit your body and your riding style.

What you need in a bike saddle for commuting

At a glance, bike saddles can look similar, but you’ll notice the difference when riding on them. With that in mind, here are the features to look for when choosing a bike saddle for commuting;

Saddles come in two shapes; wide and narrow. The saddle shape you select is vital because it will affect the amount of surface your butt will cover, as well as the position of your legs.

Wide Saddle and riding style

Wide bike saddles provide enough surface area to support your body weight. This ensures distribution of the pressure over the whole sitting surface area, which minimizes the possibilities of developing pressure points. That’s why they’re ideal for commuters who ride in an upright position, with most of their body weight on the saddle.

Narrow Saddle and riding style

Narrow saddles, on the flip side, create too much pressure on your butt. But aggressive bike riders like them because they don’t force their legs out to the sides as the wide saddles do. Narrow saddles are ideal for bike commuters who cover many miles and ride in a forward position. However, wide saddles can bring added pressure and pain for inner-city commuters.

Most saddles for commuting come with a center slit to protect the perineum, which is located between your sit bones. It contains sensitive nerves that can be painful when sitting on a saddle without a center slit, even for short-distance commutes. But some riders are okay with saddles without a slit. So, it all boils down to preference.

Conclusion

When it comes to choosing the best saddles for regular/heavy commuting, it doesn’t get better than Brooks leather saddles. They offer incredible comfort right out of the box and give you a great riding experience. They are also long-lasting because the tops are made of the finest vegetable-tanned leather. Plus, they are so durable. They’ll outlive your riding experience.

Related Readings

(Visited 778 times, 2 visits today)

Last update on 2020-09-27 at 23:50 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Dion Lewis
My name is Dion Lewis.

I’ve been cycling from my childhood. When I was in high school, I started racing in our local competitions.

At my college life, I took a part time job in a bicycle shop and I learned how to repair and maintain bicycles professionally.

Though I love racing, mountain biking is another thing I do frequently. My friends, neighbors, and colleagues treat me as an avid rider and take my suggestions while they plan for a new bike or a bike gear.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply