Disclosure: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, but this never influences our opinion.

Brooks B17 vs. C17 Cambium (Comparison & Review Sep 2020)

Brooks B17 vs. C17. Which one is better suited to which specific types of riding and maintaining certain cycling positions? Along the course of this article, we shall be providing you with an in-depth analysis and describing the similarities and differences in-between these distinguished Brooks saddles. 

Brooks is a very prominent manufacturer of cycling saddles, if not the most prominent name out there. They are very well known and revered for designing classic, leather made saddles for your cycle. Brooks originates and was founded in 1866  at Smethwick, West Midlands, England. They have started making leather-made goods and accessories since 1866. However; they did not start manufacturing and patenting bike saddles until 1882. In 2002, the owners of Brooks sold the company to Selle Royal who originates from Italy. Brooks is up there setting the standard when it comes to manufacturing well-functioning and chic leather saddles. Their leather saddles are a very popular choice among cyclists. Irrespective of the type of riding you’re into, be it road biking, cyclo-cross, mountain biking, touring, or everyday commuting. Therefore; getting yourself a Brooks saddle will serve you with the perfect blend between comfort and performance. Any professional cyclist or an avid cyclist will vouch for the quality of Brooks saddles.

The founder of Brooks saddles, John Boultbee Brooks, considered using cycles after his horse had died. However; upon using cycles, he found the saddles on them to be quite uncomfortable, especially to the sit bones. So; this is when he considered taking matters into his own hand and started manufacturing comfortable bike saddles. The elementary design of a Brooks saddle includes a comfortable and well-designed leather-made cover outstretched between metal chunk plates at the nose and aft sections of the saddle.  

The B17 and C17 are two of Brooks’s outstandingly designed and elite bike saddles. So, there were times when many cyclists were at a crossroads between these two biking saddles. Therefore; we shall be reviewing these two saddles and making an in-depth analysis between them.      

Brooks B17 Saddle

Brooks B17 happens to be one of the earliest versions of Brooks’ England saddles. These saddles are quite heavy. Also, initially right after you take these saddles out of the box, they tend to be a bit stiff. The shape of these saddles is very well designed, so that you can perfectly position your derrière, as you cycle. You may feel a bit uncomfortable sitting on these for long periods, because of its sturdiness. However, as you keep on using these saddles; these tend to soften up in the right places; molding your buttocks. Therefore, you’ll feel even more comfortable using these upon usage and progression of time. These saddles are constructed from thick leather material. Also, there are sloped bezels surrounding this saddle. There are also huge, glossy rivets made from copper. The cover of this saddle is made entirely from leather materials, meaning, you need to take proper maintenance of these in order for these saddles to survive the test of time. We advise you to use a conditioner that Brooks sells, known as Proofide. You should clean these saddles using the conditioner so that they don’t dry up too much and cause cracks. As previously stated, these saddles seamlessly adjust to your posterior as you keep using it. Lastly, if you require to make adjustments to the tension; then note that there is a tension adjusting bolt underneath the nose of this saddle. Turning these bolts every 6 months should do the trick. These saddles are perfect for commuting, trekking, touring, etc. 

Brooks C17 Cambium Saddle

  • Brooks B17 VS C17

Brooks C17 has a similar structure to that of other classical Brook saddles. However; unlike Brooks’s famous leather-made saddle, this one is made from a processed pure rubber material. Therefore; this makes the saddle waterproof. Also, it consists of a guaranteed canvas made from cotton materials. The topmost texture is textiles made. Additionally, this top portion of the saddle happens to be very flexible and the rubber-made top section is quite flexible as well. These saddles would serve you with maximum comfort. Moreover, as you sit on this saddle and pedal, it tends to move quite a bit, this slight movement does you a great deal of help in preventing any potential chafing. However, your buttocks may need some time in getting used to the shape of this saddle. Although, it would not require too much time for that to happen. This saddle also happens to be quite wide in shape. The width of this pedal won’t make you feel too uncomfortable. Rather the fact that it moves slightly does a great deal of good for you. The aluminum-made ends of the saddle have a curved design. However, weighing in at 418g, this saddle can be quite heavy, compared to many other saddles designed by Brooks. Lastly, the only major concern remains for its durability. However, you can quite easily replace the back and nose sections; as well as the rails if these ever get damaged. These saddles are perfect for road biking, commuting, etc.    

Major similarities between Brooks B17 and Brooks C17

Saddle
Brooks B17
Brooks C17
Preview
Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle - Handmade Leather Bike Seat (Steel, Titanium, Copper)
Brooks England Cambium All Weather Bike Seat - High Mileage, Waterproof, Carved/Standard Bicycle Saddle (C15, C17, C19)
Ladies variant
B17 S
C17 S
Warranty
2 years of guaranteed service and 10-year additional product warranty once you have registered this product on Brooks website
2 years of guaranteed service and 10-year additional product warranty once you have registered this product on Brooks website
Saddle type
Cruiser/Performance
Cruiser/Performance
Material for cushioning
None
None
Material of rail
Black steel
Steel
Ideal for Gender
Men
Men
Design
All-leather
All-leather/Contemporary
Saddle
Brooks B17
Preview
Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle - Handmade Leather Bike Seat (Steel, Titanium, Copper)
Ladies variant
B17 S
Warranty
2 years of guaranteed service and 10-year additional product warranty once you have registered this product on Brooks website
Saddle type
Cruiser/Performance
Material for cushioning
None
Material of rail
Black steel
Ideal for Gender
Men
Design
All-leather
Saddle
Brooks C17
Preview
Brooks England Cambium All Weather Bike Seat - High Mileage, Waterproof, Carved/Standard Bicycle Saddle (C15, C17, C19)
Ladies variant
C17 S
Warranty
2 years of guaranteed service and 10-year additional product warranty once you have registered this product on Brooks website
Saddle type
Cruiser/Performance
Material for cushioning
None
Material of rail
Steel
Ideal for Gender
Men
Design
All-leather/Contemporary

Major differences between Brooks B17 and Brooks C17

Saddle
Brooks B17
Brooks C17
Preview
Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle - Handmade Leather Bike Seat (Steel, Titanium, Copper)
Brooks England Cambium All Weather Bike Seat - High Mileage, Waterproof, Carved/Standard Bicycle Saddle (C15, C17, C19)
Type of cycling
Commuting, Trekking, Touring, etc.
Road biking, Commuting, etc.
Positioning of rider
Advised to use a seat-post. Stock position ideal for long rides. Rearward position.
Angled comfortable riding position.
Weight
1.15 lbs
0.91 lbs
Length
10.83”
11.2”
Width
6.89”
6.4”
Height
2.56”
2”
Waterproof
No
Yes
Color Variant
Black; Honey; Brown
Black, Bronze/ Orange, Octane, Beige
Cover Material
Leather
Organic Cotton
Breaking-in Time
500 km of riding; about 24h at 20 km/h
Breaking-un not required
Material of Rivet
Nickel-plated Steel
Steel, Chrome
Steel material
N/A
Natural-rubber
Extra features
Handmade-in England, Tanned leather
Handmade-in Italy, Water-resistant, Processed-rubber
Saddle
Brooks B17
Preview
Brooks England B17 Bike Saddle - Handmade Leather Bike Seat (Steel, Titanium, Copper)
Type of cycling
Commuting, Trekking, Touring, etc.
Positioning of rider
Advised to use a seat-post. Stock position ideal for long rides. Rearward position.
Weight
1.15 lbs
Length
10.83”
Width
6.89”
Height
2.56”
Waterproof
No
Color Variant
Black; Honey; Brown
Cover Material
Leather
Breaking-in Time
500 km of riding; about 24h at 20 km/h
Material of Rivet
Nickel-plated Steel
Steel material
N/A
Extra features
Handmade-in England, Tanned leather
Saddle
Brooks C17
Preview
Brooks England Cambium All Weather Bike Seat - High Mileage, Waterproof, Carved/Standard Bicycle Saddle (C15, C17, C19)
Type of cycling
Road biking, Commuting, etc.
Positioning of rider
Angled comfortable riding position.
Weight
0.91 lbs
Length
11.2”
Width
6.4”
Height
2”
Waterproof
Yes
Color Variant
Black, Bronze/ Orange, Octane, Beige
Cover Material
Organic Cotton
Breaking-in Time
Breaking-un not required
Material of Rivet
Steel, Chrome
Steel material
Natural-rubber
Extra features
Handmade-in Italy, Water-resistant, Processed-rubber

Conclusion

For you to differentiate and select your desired saddle depends on a few factors, these include; the type of bicycle you want to fit these into, the position or posture on which you prefer riding on, most of the time. Also, a lot depends on your bike’s handlebars. We will recommend you to check for the adjustability of a given saddle and how easily you can fit these saddles into your bike. So, if you are into long-duration rides or touring, then the B17 will be the ideal choice for you. Whereas the C17 should be your pick for commuting. It is very comfortable and is also very capable of serving you with optimal performance. Brooks B17 is the perfect choice for your mountain bikes. On the other hand, the C17 is perfect for your road bikes. To conclude, you will highly recommend you to precisely identify your requirement and based on that choose the saddle that your feet will tick all the boxes. Carry out proper research and analysis before you for buying a saddle for your bike. Maintaining a proper posture should be of utmost importance for you when choosing a saddle for your bike. We sincerely hope our review and in-depth analysis will help you to choose between Brooks B17 or C17. Good Luck!


Related Brooks Saddles

(Visited 91 times, 5 visits today)

Last update on 2020-09-27 at 22:10 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Dion Lewis
My name is Dion Lewis.

I’ve been cycling from my childhood. When I was in high school, I started racing in our local competitions.

At my college life, I took a part time job in a bicycle shop and I learned how to repair and maintain bicycles professionally.

Though I love racing, mountain biking is another thing I do frequently. My friends, neighbors, and colleagues treat me as an avid rider and take my suggestions while they plan for a new bike or a bike gear.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply